- CBIC Circular No. 264/10/2026-GST dated 26 October 2026 clarifies that the omission of Rule 96(10) of the CGST Rules is effective retrospectively from 23 October 2017, the date the rule first came into force.
- The clarification follows the Supreme Court judgment dated 6 August 2026 in M/s Goodluck India Limited and Anr. v. Union of India and Ors., SLP (Civil) No. 24550 of 2025, and connected matters.
- Field formations must deal with pending proceedings on Rule 96(10) in line with that judgment.
- The same treatment applies, mutatis mutandis, to the omission of Rules 89(4A) and 89(4B).
1. What Rule 96(10) did
Rule 96 of the CGST Rules governs refund of IGST paid on goods exported out of India. Sub-rule (10) was inserted with effect from 23 October 2017. Its purpose, as the circular records, was to stop a double benefit: an exporter who procured inputs without IGST under specified concessional or exemption notifications (such as the notifications covering deemed export supplies and imports by EOUs or against Advance Authorisation) could not also export on payment of IGST and claim refund of that IGST.
In practice this meant that such exporters were pushed to the other route: export under LUT or bond and claim refund of accumulated input tax credit under Rule 89. Where an exporter had used the IGST-paid route while also enjoying the input-side benefit, the department treated the IGST refund as erroneous and issued recovery notices.
2. The omission in 2024 and the dispute that followed
The 54th GST Council meeting on 9 September 2024 noted the difficulties exporters faced because of this restriction. Rule 96(10) was then omitted by the CGST (Second Amendment) Rules, 2024, notified vide Notification No. 20/2024-Central Tax dated 8 October 2024. The notification gave the omission prospective effect from 8 October 2024.
That left a large body of demands, show cause notices and appeals for the period from 23 October 2017 to 7 October 2024. Taxpayers argued that an omitted rule cannot support proceedings that were pending on the date of omission, unless the omitting notification saves them. As the circular itself records, various courts accepted this view, and the question reached the Supreme Court.
3. What the Supreme Court held
As summarised in the circular, the Supreme Court held in Goodluck India Limited that, in the absence of any saving clause or sunset clause accompanying the omission of Rule 96(10), the omission applies to all proceedings pending on the date of omission.
The Court relied on the Constitution Bench decision in Kolhapur Canesugar Works Ltd. v. Union of India. The principle restated is straightforward: when a rule is omitted, pending proceedings can continue only if there is an express provision for their continuance, or a legal device in the statute or rules that preserves them. Notification No. 20/2024-Central Tax contained no such saving.
4. What CBIC has now clarified
Paragraph 6 of the circular contains the operative clarification. In view of the Supreme Court decision, the omission of Rule 96(10) is effective retrospectively from 23 October 2017, and field formations are advised to deal with pending proceedings concerning Rule 96(10) in accordance with the judgment.
The circular states that the same treatment applies, mutatis mutandis, to the omission of Rules 89(4A) and 89(4B). These sub-rules modified how refund of input tax credit was computed for exporters who had received inputs under the same concessional notifications. Pending disputes on those sub-rules should now be handled on the same footing as Rule 96(10).
5. Who is affected and how
| Your position | Likely effect of Circular 264 |
|---|---|
| Show cause notice issued, not yet adjudicated | The proceeding is a pending proceeding. The adjudicating authority is required to follow the judgment, which removes the basis for a demand founded only on Rule 96(10). |
| Order confirmed, first appeal pending | The appeal is pending. Place the circular and the judgment on record before the Appellate Authority. |
| Appeal pending before the Tribunal or a High Court | Same principle. File an application or written note citing the circular so that the matter is listed and disposed of on this ground. |
| Recovery already made, or pre-deposit paid | Examine refund of the amount recovered and of the pre-deposit after the appeal is decided. Interest on pre-deposit refunds is dealt with in Circular 259/05/2026-GST. |
| IGST refund withheld or rejected on Rule 96(10) ground | Request re-examination of the claim, citing the circular. Where an order has attained finality, take advice on the remedy available. |
The judgment, as recorded in the circular, speaks of proceedings pending on the date of omission. Whether a matter that had already concluded, with no appeal pending, can be reopened is a separate question. Each case needs to be examined on its own facts and procedural history.
6. Practical action points for exporters
- List every notice, order, appeal and refund rejection in which Rule 96(10), Rule 89(4A) or Rule 89(4B) is the ground, with period, amount and current stage.
- For each live matter, file a short written submission citing Circular 264/10/2026-GST and the Goodluck India judgment. Ask for the matter to be disposed of on this ground.
- Check whether any demand also rests on another ground, such as a valuation or eligibility issue. The circular addresses only the Rule 96(10) ground.
- Track pre-deposits and amounts paid under protest. Plan refund applications once favourable orders are received.
- Keep the procurement records (authorisations, EOU documents, bills of entry) ready. The officer may still verify facts while closing the matter.
7. Our view
For exporters, this circular is a significant relief. Demands under Rule 96(10) were among the largest refund disputes in GST, often involving the entire IGST refunded over several years. With the Board now accepting the retrospective effect, pending matters on this ground should move to closure without further rounds of litigation. The practical work now lies in identifying every affected file and getting it disposed of in writing.
Frequently asked questions
Is the omission of Rule 96(10) now retrospective?
Which Supreme Court judgment does the circular follow?
Does the circular apply to Rules 89(4A) and 89(4B)?
What should I do if I have a pending appeal on a Rule 96(10) demand?
Can a concluded case be reopened because of this circular?
This article summarises the circular for general information. It is not professional advice and does not create a professional relationship. Read the official circular and the applicable law, and take advice on your specific facts before acting. Content is current as at the date of publication.