- Pre-SCN intimation in Part A of DRC-01A should be issued wherever feasible, so the taxpayer can explain before formal proceedings.
- An SCN must state facts, evidence, the provisions contravened, the role of each noticee and a year-wise quantified demand. Deficiencies in an SCN cannot be cured later.
- Section 74 or 74A(5)(ii) (fraud, wilful misstatement, suppression) can be invoked only where evidence of intent to evade tax is set out in the SCN. Not merely because a discrepancy is found in scrutiny.
- Maximum four personal hearing opportunities, virtual hearing encouraged, order preferably within one month of hearing, fresh hearing if the officer changes.
- Orders must be speaking orders that deal with every submission and every case law cited. AI tools may be used only with human verification.
- Section 161 rectification is limited to errors apparent on the face of the record and must be done by the issuing authority itself.
- First appeals: limitation to be decided first as a preliminary issue, merits not to be rejected at registration stage, additional evidence only under Rule 112, decision ideally within one year.
1. Purpose of the circular
Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST dated 26 October 2026 responds to representations that adjudication and appellate orders often fail to examine the taxpayer's submissions, evidence and case law, leading to avoidable litigation and remands. The Board has issued guidelines under section 168(1) of the CGST Act to bring consistency to quasi-judicial work across field formations.
The guidelines are written for officers. For taxpayers and professionals, they are a practical benchmark: each paragraph is a test that a notice or order should pass.
2. What a valid show cause notice must contain
The circular describes the SCN as the foundational document of the proceeding, grounded in the audi alteram partem rule. Summaries must be issued electronically in DRC-01 (and DRC-02 for statements) on the common portal. A well-drafted SCN should ideally contain:
| Part | What it should cover | Use in your reply |
|---|---|---|
| Profile and introduction | Name, GSTIN, registration status, jurisdiction, tax periods, separate particulars for each noticee, and how the case arose (audit, scrutiny, investigation) | Check the period and the source of proceedings |
| Facts and evidence | Specific acts or omissions, evidence examined objectively, neutral language, no pre-judged conclusions | Challenge conclusions not supported by evidence on record |
| Legal framework | Each provision allegedly contravened, linked to the facts; no unrelated sections; role of each noticee spelt out | Object to omnibus invocation of sections |
| Statement of charges | Concise allegations and grounds | Deficiencies cannot be cured later |
| Quantification | Demand quantified with basis, demarcated financial year-wise; interest proposed | Seek year-wise working where it is missing |
| Conclusion | Adjudicating authority, reply deadline, consequences | Diarise the reply date |
The circular refers to the Supreme Court decision in G.R. Infra Project Ltd. v. State of Madhya Pradesh, (2026) 45 Centax 331 (S.C.), dated 19 August 2026, for the principle that what is needed to sustain a notice or order must be contained in it, and any deficiency, including non-application of mind, cannot be cured subsequently.
3. Fraud, wilful misstatement and suppression: a higher bar
This part will matter most in day-to-day litigation. The circular states that:
- The SCN must specifically disclose the basis for invoking section 74(1) or section 74A(5)(ii). Mechanical use of the words "fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts" without the material that led to that inference does not suffice. The circular relies on the same G.R. Infra Project judgment.
- Suppression or misstatement must be deliberate and aimed at evading tax. A mere omission to furnish correct information is not suppression unless intentional. Where facts are known to both parties, an omission by one is not suppression.
- These provisions are not to be applied in scrutiny cases solely because a discrepancy has been noticed. They may be invoked only where investigation discloses material evidence, which must be set out in the SCN.
- A second SCN for a subsequent period on the same facts and grounds generally cannot invoke fraud or suppression unless new and independent grounds exist. Subsequent statements should typically be under section 73 or 74A(5)(i).
- Where an SCN covers both sections 73 and 74, it must give separate reasons and separate quantification. For section 74A (from FY 2024-25), the two sets of facts must be delineated separately.
Where an SCN invokes the extended period without spelling out evidence of intent, raise this as a preliminary objection in the reply. Paragraph 13 of the circular directs the adjudicating authority to record findings on this and confine the demand to section 73 or 74A(5)(i) where intent is not established.
4. Parallel proceedings, timing and service
- No parallel proceedings: section 6 bars a central officer from initiating proceedings on the same subject matter already taken up by a State officer, and vice versa. The circular asks officers to follow the guidelines in para 97 of Armour Security (India) Ltd. v. Commissioner, CGST, Delhi East, (2025) 33 Centax 222 (S.C.).
- Timing: notices should be issued well before the time limits in sections 73(10), 74(10) and 74A(7), avoiding last-minute issue.
- Service: through the modes in section 169, with the summary uploaded on the portal.
5. Personal hearings
Section 75(4) requires a hearing on written request or where an adverse decision is contemplated. The circular adds:
- Since section 75(5) allows no more than three adjournments, a maximum of four hearing opportunities may be granted. Refusal of an adjournment request must be reasoned in writing.
- Appearance by authorised representatives under section 116 should be considered. Virtual hearings may be offered.
- Records of each hearing, including date, time and attendees, should be kept and incorporated in the order.
- The order should be communicated promptly after the hearing, preferably within one month.
- If the adjudicating authority is transferred, the successor must give a fresh hearing.
6. The adjudication order must be a speaking order
Summaries must be uploaded in DRC-07. Beyond form, the circular requires that the order:
- Sets out the issues for determination and examines evidence critically against each allegation.
- Deals with each submission in DRC-06 and at the hearing, stating whether it is accepted, partly accepted or rejected, with reasons. Generic expressions are to be avoided.
- Stays within the grounds and amounts in the SCN, as section 75(7) requires. New issues need a separate SCN.
- Discusses case law cited by both sides, verifies citations and their current status, and gives reasons where a judgment is held inapplicable.
- Quantifies tax, interest and penalty issue-wise and year-wise, separately under CGST, SGST, IGST and UTGST, adjusts amounts already paid, and does not leave the demand open-ended.
- Records reasons before imposing penalty, keeping section 126 in view.
Paragraph 11.7.1 permits officers to use AI and other technology tools, but only with human oversight. Information from AI tools must be independently verified before it is relied on, and responsibility for the order stays with the issuing authority.
7. Rectification under section 161
An application may be filed within three months of the order, and rectification should be done within six months, except for purely clerical or arithmetical errors. The circular stresses three limits:
- Only the authority that issued the document can rectify it. Senior officers cannot use section 5(2) to do so.
- Only errors apparent on the face of the record qualify. An error that needs long reasoning, verification of transactions or is open to debate does not, citing Arun Dev Upadhyaya v. Integrated Sales Service Ltd., (2023) 8 SCC 11.
- Rectification is not a substitute for appeal. Requests are to be disposed of expeditiously in DRC-08.
8. First appeals
| Issue | Guideline |
|---|---|
| Registration of appeal | Preliminary scrutiny under Rule 108 for maintainability and completeness. Merits must not be decided at this stage. |
| Limitation | Three months from communication, plus one month on sufficient cause (section 107(1) and (4)). Decide limitation first. An appeal beyond the condonable period is not to be heard on merits. |
| Withdrawal | Rule 109C, APL-01/03W. After APL-02, needs approval, to be decided within seven days. |
| Hearings | Dates communicated on the portal; proceedings recorded and reflected in the appellate order. |
| Additional grounds | Section 107(10): allowed where omission was not wilful or unreasonable. New factual issues needing investigation are generally not entertained. |
| Additional evidence | Only within Rule 112, with reasons, opportunity to the adjudicating authority to rebut, and no conversion of the appeal into a fresh investigation. |
| Time for decision | As far as possible within one year of filing (section 107(13)). |
| Cross appeals | Heard together and decided by a common order. Summary in APL-04 showing the final demand. |
Paragraphs 10, 11 and 13 (natural justice, speaking orders and the fraud-suppression test) apply to appellate authorities as well.
9. How taxpayers can use these guidelines
Paragraph 17 states that the guidelines are illustrative, non-exhaustive, and must not be cited by proper officers in notices or orders. That restriction is on officers. For taxpayers, the circular remains a useful statement of the Board's own expectations, and many of its points restate statutory provisions and Supreme Court decisions that can be relied on directly.
- On receiving an SCN, test it against the six-part structure. List missing facts, evidence, year-wise quantification and noticee-wise roles.
- Where section 74 or 74A(5)(ii) is invoked, check whether the SCN discloses evidence of intent. If not, raise it as a preliminary objection.
- Request hearings in writing and keep proof of every adjournment request and appearance.
- On receiving an order, check whether each submission and each judgment cited by you is dealt with. Gaps are strong appeal grounds.
- Use section 161 only for patent errors. For anything arguable, file an appeal within the limitation period.
Frequently asked questions
Can section 74 be invoked just because a discrepancy was found in GST scrutiny?
How many personal hearings will be given in GST adjudication?
Can a defective SCN be corrected in the adjudication order?
What errors can be corrected under section 161?
Will a first appeal filed late be heard on merits?
This article summarises the circular for general information. It is not professional advice and does not create a professional relationship. Read the official circular and the applicable law, and take advice on your specific facts before acting. Content is current as at the date of publication.